Working at page or separate website?

A careers page on your company website is sufficient if you have few vacancies and your website is well managed. A separate careers website is better suited if you are recruiting structurally, have multiple target groups, or want to tell your own employer story. A subdomain is in between. Below you will find the considerations for each topic.

Working at page or separate website?

Careers page or careers site: which do you need?

Search for “careers site” or “careers page” and you’ll mainly find two kinds of articles. One lists the benefits of a separate careers site, the other explains why you don’t need one. Both are usually written by a company that sells exactly that one product. In this article we put the two options side by side, including the in-between option that often gets overlooked: the subdomain.

What is the difference between a careers page and a careers site?

A careers page is a page (or a few pages) within your existing company website, for example company.com/careers. A careers site is a separate website intended only for candidates, at its own address such as companycareers.com or careers.company.com.

So the difference goes beyond the address. A careers page shares the menu, design, CMS and administrator with the rest of your website. A careers site has its own homepage, its own menu and often its own administrator, usually HR or recruitment. If you first want to know exactly what belongs on such a page, read what is a careers page.

Careers page or separate site: the comparison

The short answer: a page is cheaper and simpler, a separate site gives you more room and more control. The overview shows exactly where the differences lie.

Address

  • Careers page (company.com/careers): Subpage on your existing domain
  • Separate careers site (own domain or subdomain): Own domain (companycareers.com) or subdomain (careers.company.com)

Who manages it

  • Careers page: Usually marketing or the company website’s administrator
  • Separate careers site: Usually HR or recruitment themselves

Maintenance

  • Careers page: Runs alongside the company website; vacancies often added manually or via an ATS widget
  • Separate careers site: Maintained separately, unless vacancies come automatically from your ATS

Costs

  • Careers page: Low if your CMS supports it; a custom vacancy module costs extra
  • Separate careers site: Build or subscription, plus hosting and domain. Depends heavily on the approach

Findability

  • Careers page: Benefits from the authority your company domain already has
  • Separate careers site: Has to build its own authority; but fully focused on vacancy and employer search terms

Google for Jobs

  • Careers page: Possible, if every vacancy has its own page with JobPosting data
  • Separate careers site: Possible, under the same condition

Employer branding

  • Careers page: Limited to the style and menu of your company website
  • Separate careers site: Its own tone, its own visuals, its own story for candidates

Measurement

  • Careers page: Applicant traffic is mixed in with customer traffic in your analytics
  • Separate careers site: All visitors are (potential) candidates, so the figures are cleaner

Two rows in the overview deserve more explanation: findability and Google for Jobs. We cover them below.

Choose a careers page if…

  • you only have a handful of vacancies per year and they don’t stay open long;
  • your company website has a CMS in which you can quickly post a vacancy yourself, with a separate page per vacancy;
  • marketing and HR work well together and it’s no problem for the web administrator to also keep vacancies up to date;
  • your employer story is short and fits the tone of your company website;
  • your budget and time are limited and you’d rather maintain one site well than two sites half-heartedly.

Choose a separate careers site if…

  • you recruit continuously or have many vacancies open at once;
  • you address multiple target groups, for example care staff, technicians and office roles, or multiple locations;
  • as an employer you want to project something different from what your company projects to customers;
  • HR or recruitment want to publish themselves, without waiting for marketing or a web agency;
  • your vacancies are already in an ATS and you don’t want to retype them;
  • you want to measure separately what your recruitment channels deliver.

Not sure? Start with the question of how much you have to say about working for you. A few vacancies and a paragraph about the atmosphere fit perfectly well on a page. Team stories, a blog, an explanation of the application process and vacancies per field of work need more room. For examples of what that looks like, see careers site examples.

How does your choice affect your findability in Google?

Findability depends less on the format than many articles claim. Whether a vacancy is found is mainly determined by the content of the page, the technology behind it and how well the site is linked internally and externally.

What is true:

  • A subpage inherits the strength of your company domain. If company.com has had good links and traffic for years, company.com/careers doesn’t start from zero. That is the strongest argument for a careers page.
  • A new domain does start from zero. companycareers.com has no links and no history at launch. It needs time and referrals, for example a clear link from your company website, from job platforms and from your social channels.
  • A separate site is fully focused. Every page is about working for you. That makes it easier to rank for searches like “careers at [company name]” or “[job title] [location]”, because the site doesn’t also have to explain products or services.
  • If candidates search for your company name, the format makes little difference. For “careers at [company name]”, a well-built page or site will usually rank at the top on its own, as long as that search term is in the title and the heading.

What isn’t true: that Google automatically ranks a separate careers site higher, or that a subpage always performs better. Neither is a fixed rule. A slow, outdated careers page will lose to a fast site with up-to-date vacancies, and vice versa.

What about Google for Jobs?

Google for Jobs works the same way on a page, a subdomain and a separate domain. The condition is that every vacancy has its own page with structured data of the JobPosting type, as described in Google’s official documentation.

In practice, the technology of your CMS decides it, and the address hardly matters. Many company websites show vacancies via a list or an embedded ATS widget. In that case each vacancy doesn’t have its own page on your domain, or the JobPosting data is missing. Check this before you choose. How it works exactly and which fields Google requires, you can read in our article on Google for Jobs.

A subdomain as a middle option: what are the consequences?

A subdomain such as careers.company.com feels like a nice middle ground: your company name stays in the address, and you still have your own site. For candidates that holds true. They immediately see that the site belongs to you.

For search engines it’s more nuanced. In practice, Google largely treats a subdomain as a separate site. Like a separate domain, a subdomain builds its own authority and benefits only to a limited extent from the links company.com already has. This means:

  • In terms of findability, you start roughly as you would with a new domain. Don’t overestimate the advantage of “it belongs to our main domain”.
  • A subdomain is easy to separate technically. It runs on its own platform, independent of your company website, without you having to change the company website. That is often the real reason to choose it.
  • In Google Search Console, a subdomain falls under a domain property of company.com, but you can also add it separately to see its figures on their own.
  • Link prominently from your main site. Put “Careers” in the main menu and footer of company.com. That helps both candidates and search engines connect the two sites.

If you’re choosing between a subdomain and a separate domain such as companycareers.com, the difference for search engines is small. It’s mainly about recognisability: a subdomain shows which company the site belongs to, a separate domain is shorter to remember and say out loud, for example in a radio ad or on a bus.

What does a careers page or site cost?

A careers page seems free, but it rarely is. Someone has to post and remove vacancies, and if your CMS has no vacancy module, you pay a web agency to build one. Also count the hours of whoever retypes vacancies from your ATS.

A separate careers site can be built by an agency, as a custom build on WordPress or another CMS, or you can take out a subscription to a ready-made careers site. With an agency you usually pay a one-off build fee, followed by hosting, maintenance and a quote for every change. With a subscription you pay per month. Read more about the options in having a careers site built.

Recruit Website is such a subscription: from €100 per month on an annual contract, or €125 per month on a monthly contract, excluding VAT. Hosting, SSL, backups, updates and your own domain are included.

Who maintains the site, and how much work is it?

With both options, the biggest task is the same: keeping vacancies up to date. A vacancy that has already been filled but is still online costs you candidates’ trust. On a careers page this often happens because the web administrator doesn’t know a vacancy has closed.

If your vacancies come from an ATS, an integration is the most reliable answer, whichever format you choose. With Recruit Website, vacancies come automatically from your ATS (we integrate with more than 30 systems) and closed vacancies disappear on their own. You edit texts, pages and photos yourself in the page editor. You can see which ATSs can be connected at nubos.nl/nl/ats.

What does your choice mean for employer branding?

A separate site gives you more room for your employer brand. You do have to fill that room, though. A careers page with real photos, an honest description of the work and a clear application process is more convincing than a separate site full of stock images.

A separate site mainly helps if your employer story differs from your customer story. An installation company that promises customers “certainty” may want to show candidates “variety and personal responsibility” instead. On a single site, those messages quickly clash. Read what employer branding involves in what is employer branding.

Frequently asked questions

Which is better: a careers page or a careers site?

Neither is always better. A careers page suits an organisation with few vacancies and a well-managed company website. A separate careers site suits organisations that recruit continuously, have multiple target groups or want HR to publish themselves.

Is a careers site bad for my SEO?

No, but a new careers site starts without built-up authority. That applies to a separate domain and, in practice, to a subdomain too. With a clear link from your company website, up-to-date vacancies and solid technology, you build that authority. Your company website loses nothing as a result.

Should I choose careers.company.com or companycareers.com?

For search engines the difference is small, because both build their own authority. A subdomain immediately shows which company the site belongs to. A separate domain is shorter and easier to remember in campaigns.

Do vacancies on a careers page also appear in Google for Jobs?

Yes, if every vacancy has its own page with structured data of the JobPosting type. The address doesn’t matter. If your company website only shows vacancies in a list or via an embedded widget, it often won’t work.

What are the advantages of a separate careers site?

You have more room for your employer story, a site fully focused on candidates and cleaner figures in your analytics. HR or recruitment can publish themselves. The downside: you have a second site to maintain and the domain has to build its own authority.

Can I switch from a page to a separate site later?

Yes. When switching, set up a 301 redirect from every old URL to the new one, so visitors and search engines end up in the right place. Link from your company website to the new careers site.

Try a careers site without double work

Want a separate careers site where your vacancies come automatically from your ATS and that you maintain yourself? Try Recruit Website for 14 days at no cost. You’ll immediately see what your careers site looks like and can edit the texts yourself.

Start your trial